Come for the pizza, stay for the bagels

My first visit to Cleveland, Mississippi, was in 1990. My high school sweetheart was going to Delta State to become a pilot, and he thought he might entice me to enroll there. My only memory from our visit was a liquor store with a drive-through window, which seemed amazing at the time.
I’ve been back to Cleveland several times over the last few years. The Cotton House hotel graciously hosted me on several occasions while I tried Cleveland’s restaurant offerings, took in the Christmas lights on Main Street, attended a special dinner in conjunction with Vishwesh Bhatt’s cookbook release, and checked out Leña, a neighboring restaurant that specializes in Neapolitan pizza and wood-fired bagels. It’s Leña that made me finally sit down and write about this sweet town, just a two-hour drive away.

Getting there
Getting to Cleveland is half the fun.
I recommend getting up early and having breakfast and coffee at the Blue & White diner just outside of Tunica. Or have an early lunch (and a slice of pie) at the Rest Haven in Clarksdale. (While you’re there, you might as well get a dozen tamales at Hick’s for late-night snacking.)
Just before Cleveland is the little town of Merigold, which is primarily known to Memphians as the home of McCartys Pottery. I absolutely recommend stopping into the world’s smallest showroom of handcrafted platters, wind chimes, mugs, bunnies, birds, and more. And if you are a fan of McCartys, then stop first at Peter’s Pottery in nearby Mound Bayou. Peter worked for the McCartys until he saved up enough to open his own business and create his own designs.
Just across the highway from McCartys is what’s left of Po’ Monkey’s juke joint. Definitely swing by to read the historical marker and snap a pic.

Where to stay
I have always stayed at the Cotton House hotel on Cleveland’s Cotton Row. (It’s a Tribute Portfolio hotel by Marriott.) It’s got everything you need. The Delta Meat Market serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and you can visit the rooftop Bar Fontaine for a nightcap, small plates, and live entertainment. Both feature dishes from James Beard Award-nominated chef Cole Ellis. [Editor’s Note: Staple Food & Drink is replacing Delta Meat market this fall.]
What to do between meals
There are tons of little shops within walking distance of the hotel, including several antique stores. My favorite is the Moonstruck Flea Market, which houses over 8000 square feet of antiques and vintage collectibles from more than 25 vendors.
A short drive away is the Grammy Museum, which I will make it to one of these days!

So nice, you better go twice
Leña makes Neapolitan pizzas Thursday to Saturday nights from 5 to 9 p.m. and wood-fired bagels on Saturday mornings only from 9 a.m. to sellout, or noon. The pro move is to go to Leña for dinner on Friday, spend the night at Cotton House, and visit Leña again for breakfast on Saturday. Or you could totally do breakfast and dinner on a Saturday with all the other stuff I mentioned in between and call it a daytrip!
Ok, let’s talk about lenapizzabagels. (That’s their Instagram handle and what I like to call them.) It’s owned by Marisol and Rory Doyle. Marisol, who was born in Mexico, is a 20-year veteran of the hospitality industry. She met Rory, a photojournalist, in Phoenix back in 2006. They traveled around a good bit together, and she says that one of the best things early on was taking Rory to Mexico to introduce him to her family and all of the amazing food she grew up on.
They moved to Cleveland, Mississippi, in 2009 when Rory went to Delta State University for grad school. She says, “We didn’t know anything about Mississippi before moving, and I’ll never forget packing up our tiny little car and driving from Arizona to Mississippi to start a new path.
We quickly fell in love with the small-town feel of the Delta, and we felt very welcomed by the community.”

Marisol describes Cleveland as a nice little town, where everybody knows everybody. “We have a great seasonal farmers market that takes place right outside Leña. We also have a pretty cool music scene because of all the music history tied to the Mississippi Delta,” she says. “Cleveland is pretty close to the Mississippi River, and there’s a great little state park in Rosedale where you can hike right up to the banks of the big river. It’s a beautiful and quiet spot to catch the sunset.”
Rory and Marisol always talked about opening their own place, but she says it seemed like a dream that they never expected to accomplish. After running a small bagel company with a business partner for about five years, and getting more comfortable working with dough, she decided to learn the traditions of Neapolitan pizza-making. “The pizza dough is a totally different process, but I studied pretty seriously in Naples, Italy, so we could bring back this style to the rural Delta,” she says. “We wanted to offer a new dining option here, and we really feel like we’ve accomplished that with Leña.”
Their number one pizza seller is the Pepperory, named after Rory. It features house tomato sauce, basil, mozzarella, and a hearty serving of pepperoni. But Marisol says a good way to judge a Neapolitan pizzeria is to try the ultimate classic, the Margherita. Simple, traditional, and very flavorful, it features their house tomato sauce, Parmesan, basil, fresh mozzarella, and olive oil. For bagels, she highly recommends the everything bagel, covered in poppy seeds, sesame seeds, garlic, onion flakes, and salt.

“We mix up our bagel flavors every week, as well as our custom cream cheeses, like our roasted garlic cream cheese. We also make fresh focaccia bread and recommend the soppressata focaccia sandwich—fresh mozzarella, arugula, olive oil-lemon drizzle, and arugula-basil pesto,” she says.
Marisol and Rory still love traveling. Rory recently returned from Egypt, and the couple is planning another trip to Italy. “Naples has become a very special place for us, and we’re going back later this year to keep learning and observing the proud traditions of Neapolitan pizzerias. It’s really cool to see what pizza means to their culture and how they take it to the next level in terms of experience,” says Marisol.
“We try and replicate a lot of that at Leña, and we hope our customers pick up on the fact that we’re quite different from the normal American pizza place. I’ve been very fortunate to train and learn from the best at Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana [the True Neapolitan Pizza Association, a nonprofit that promotes and protects true Neapolitan pizza in Italy and worldwide], and we’re going to keep striving for incredibly tasty pizza and bagels here in small-town Mississippi. Come see us!”

On the way
Blue & White
1355 Highway 61 North, Tunica, MS
blueandwhiterestaurant.com
Rest Haven
419 State Street, Clarksdale, MS
McCartys Pottery
101 Saint Marys Street, Merigold, MS
mccartyspottery.com
Peter’s Pottery
301 Fortune Avenue, Mound Bayou, MS
peterspottery.art
In Cleveland
Cotton House
Staple Food & Drink
Bar Fontaine
215 Cotton Row
cottonhousecleveland.com
Leña
331 Cotton Row
lenapizzabagels.com
Moonstruck Flea Market
150 East North Street
moonstruckfleamarket.com
Grammy Museum
800 West Sunflower Road
grammymuseumms.org
Stacey Greenberg is the editor in chief of Edible Memphis. You can follow her at @nancy_jew.
Rory Doyle is a working photographer based in Cleveland, Mississippi. Rory has exhibited in New York, London, Atlanta, Mississippi, and beyond. His work has been published in The New York Times, Washington Post, Smithsonian Magazine, Reuters, Wall Street Journal, ProPublica, ESPN, The Nature Conservancy, The Guardian, CNN, Huff Post, and numerous outlets. @rorydoylephoto